The old tried and trusted drugs are better
Saturday, September 27th, 2008Australian medics have just finished one of the world’s biggest studies into the treatment of pneumonia. Working for the University of Melbourne, Dr Patrick Charles took samples from 885 patients diagnosed with pneumonia in five hospitals over a two year period. He analysed swabs taken from the nose and throat, and samples of blood, sputum and urine.
He found that 95% of these patients had infections that could be treated with combination of penicillin and Doxycycline. In other words, almost all the people who fell sick, were victims of bacteria easily susceptible to the older drugs. They were all from nursing homes and other residential facilities where people had picked up bacteria resistant to the older cheap antibiotics.
There was no need to use the more expensive, broad-spectrum antibiotics. So what about the other 5% of patients? The moral of this research is very clear. You’ll do just as well by relying on penicillin and the other atypical antibiotics like Doxycycline. Don’t be misled by sharp advertising put out by the pharmaceutical industry. More importantly, don’t give all bacteria the chance to become resistant to the newer drugs. Save them for when the need is greatest (as in when you’re visiting a hospital or nursing home).